This bug will kill supervisors
Affects Version/s: 0.9.2-incubating, 0.9.3, 0.9.4
Fix Version/s: 0.10.0, 0.9.5
问题背景
最近发现刚搭起的Storm集群,没过多久,Supervisor 便悄然死去了一大半。查看死去Supervisor的log,发现java.io.FileNotFoundException: File '../stormconf.ser' does not exist异常。网上给出的答案大多是
将 { storm.local.dir } 目录下的文件清空,重启就好了。
但这是指标不治本,即时重启可以跑起来,可是为什么会出现这个问题,依然不知道。
然后才发现线STORM-130解决了这个问题。该问题的重现场景:
1) Run a storm cluster with atleast 2 supervisors with 4 slots each
2) Deploy a topology that uses 4 workers, topology will be distributed with each supervisor having two workers each
3) kill one of the supervisor lets say supervisor1
4) wait till topology re-balances to occupy 4 workers on supervisor2
5) now bring up supervisor1, It goes through the cycle of cleaning up old topology code
6) nimbus re-balances topology which triggers supervisor.sync-process method
7) sync-process tries to launch a worker for the topology whose code data is delete when the supervisor started causing it throw up following exception
问题原因
上面场景分析提到的 sync-process是supervisor运行的一个函数。Supervisor会在后台运行这两个函数:
synchronize-supervisor
: This is called whenever assignments in Zookeeper change and also every 10 seconds.
- Downloads code from Nimbus for topologies assigned to this machine for which it doesn't have the code yet.
- Writes into local filesystem what this node is supposed to be running. It writes a map from port -> LocalAssignment. LocalAssignment contains a topology id as well as the list of task ids for that worker.
- Downloads code from Nimbus for topologies assigned to this machine for which it doesn't have the code yet.
sync-processes
: Reads from the LFS whatsynchronize-supervisor
wrote and compares that to what's actually running on the machine. It then starts/stops worker processes as necessary to synchronize.
从描述中可以看出,synchronized-supervisor 和 sync-process 两个函数是通过 LFS 进行同步。The key reason is "synchronize-supervisor" which responsible for download file and remove file thread and "sync-processes" which responsible for start worker process thread is Asynchronous.
in synchronize-supervisor read assigment information from zk, supervisor download necessary file from nimbus and write local state. In aother thread sync-processes funciton read local state to launch workor process, when the worker process has not start ,synchronize-supervisor function is called again topology's assignment information has changed (cased by rebalance,or worker time out etc) worker assignment to this supervisor has move to another supervisor, synchronize-supervisor remove the unnecessary file (jar file and ser file etc.) , after this, worker launched by " sync-processes" ,ser file was not exsit , this issue occur.
可能解决办法
- 换一个storm
- 调整参数
- Change "synchronize-supervisor" thread loop time to a longger than 10(default time) sec, such as 30 sec。
- supervisor.worker.timeout.secs: 30 -> 5
References:
- https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/STORM-130
- http://storm.apache.org/documentation/Lifecycle-of-a-topology.html