• 论文写回复信response时的一些参考


    首先,response的时态:一般现在时,现在完成时。

    List of Responses
    Dear Editors and Reviewers:
    Thank you for your letter and for the reviewers’ comments concerning our manuscript entitled “Paper Title” (ID: 文章稿号). Those comments are all valuable and very helpful for revising and improving our paper, as well as the important guiding significance to our researches. We have studied comments carefully and have made correction which we hope meet with approval. Revised portion are marked in red in the paper. The main corrections in the paper and the responds to the reviewer’s comments are as flowing:
    Responds to the reviewer’s comments:
    Reviewer #1:
    1. Response to comment: (……简要列出意见……)
    Response: ××××××
    2. Response to comment: (……简要列出意见……)
    Response: ××××××
    。。。。。。
    逐条意见回答,切忌一定不能有遗漏
    针对不同的问题有下列几个礼貌术语可适当用用:

    Thank you for your positive comments.

    Thank you for your support.

    Thank you for your insightful comments.

    Thank you for your helpful comments.

    Thank you for your advice.

    Thanks for your helpful comments.

    In the revised manuscript, we have added...

    In the revised manuscript, we have discussed...

    Thank you for pointing out the limitation of our work.

    Thanks for your comment. We have corrected these mistakes and highlighted them in the revised manuscript.

    We fully agree with your comments that FPN and knowledge distillation are very common in the detection task and incremental learning respectively. By enjoying the best of both worlds, we propose to address the incremental object detection problem in

    the remote sensing field and achieve promising results compared to other state-of-art methods.


    We are very sorry for our negligence of ……...
    We are very sorry for our incorrect writing ……...
    It is really true as Reviewer suggested that……
    We have made correction according to the Reviewer’s comments.
    We have re-written this part according to the Reviewer’s suggestion
    As Reviewer suggested that……
    Considering the Reviewer’s suggestion, we have ……
    最后特意感谢一下这个审稿人的意见:
    Special thanks to you for your good comments.
    Reviewer #2:
    同上述
    Reviewer #3:
        ××××××
    Other changes:
    1. Line 60-61, the statements of “……” were corrected as “…………”
    2. Line 107, “……” was added
    3. Line 129, “……” was deleted
        ××××××
        We tried our best to improve the manuscript and made some changes in the manuscript.  These changes will not influence the content and framework of the paper. And here we did not list the changes but marked in red in revised paper.
    We appreciate for Editors/Reviewers’ warm work earnestly, and hope that the correction will meet with approval.
    Once again, thank you very much for your comments and suggestions.

    以上摘自:【分享】SCI投稿信模板

    下面把我平时总结的一些答复审稿人的策略和写回复信的格式和技巧跟大家交流一下。

    首先,绝对服从编辑的意见。在审稿人给出各自的意见之后,编辑一般不会再提出自己的意见。但是,编辑一旦提出某些意见,就意味着他认为这是文章里的重大缺陷,至少是不合他的口味。这时,我们唯一能够做的只能是服从。因为毕竟是人家掌握着生杀予夺的大权。

    第二,永远不要跟审稿人争执。跟审稿人起争执是非常不明智的一件事情。审稿人意见如果正确那就不用说了,直接照办就是。如果不正确的话,也大可不必在回复中冷嘲热讽,心平气和的说明白就是了。大家都是青年人,血气方刚,被人拍了当然不爽,被人错拍了就更不爽了。尤其是一些名门正派里的弟子,看到一审结果是major而不是minor本来就已经很不爽了,难得抓住审稿人的尾巴,恨不得拖出来打死。有次审稿,一个审稿人给的意见是增加两篇参考文献(估计也就是审稿人自己的文章啦),结果作者在回复中写到,making a reference is not charity!看到之后我当时就笑喷了,可以想象审稿人得被噎成什么样。正如大家所想的那样,这篇稿子理所当然的被拒了,虽然后来经编辑调解改成了major revision,但毕竟耽误的是作者自己的时间不是?

    第三,合理掌握修改和argue的分寸。所谓修改就是对文章内容进行的修改和补充,所谓argue就是在回复信中对审稿人的答复。这其中大有文章可做,中心思想就是容易改的照改,不容易改的或者不想改的跟审稿人argue。对于语法、拼写错误、某些词汇的更换、对某些公式和图表做进一步解释等相对容易做到的修改,一定要一毫不差的根据审稿意见照做。而对于新意不足、创新性不够这类根本没法改的,还有诸如跟算法A,B,C,D做比较,补充大量实验等短时间内根本没法完成的任务,我们则要有理有据的argue。在Argue的时候首先要肯定审稿人说的很对,他提出的方法也很好,但本文的重点是blablabla,跟他说的不是一回事。然后为了表示对审稿人的尊重,象征性的在文中加上一段这方面的discussion,这样既照顾到了审稿人的面子,编辑那也能交待的过去。

    第四,聪明的掌握修改时间。拿到审稿意见,如果是minor,意见只有寥寥数行,那当然会情不自禁的一蹴而就,一天甚至几小时搞定修改稿。这时候,问题在于要不要马上投回去了?我的意见是放一放,多看一看,两个星期之后再投出去。这样首先避免了由于大喜过望而没能及时检查出的小毛病,还不会让编辑觉得你是在敷衍他。如果结果是major,建议至少放一个月再投出去,显得比较郑重。

    以上摘自:SCI答复审稿人的回信技巧

  • 相关阅读:
    Android获取两条线之间的夹角度数
    Android字体度量(FontMetrics)
    Android下如何计算要显示的字符串所占的宽度和高度
    Android 颜色渲染PorterDuff及Xfermode详解
    从输入URL到页面加载的全过程
    滚动优化
    常用的前端相关chrome插件
    DNS预解析prefetch
    资源预加载preload和资源预读取prefetch简明学习
    使用chrome开发者工具中的performance面板解决性能瓶颈
  • 原文地址:https://www.cnblogs.com/picassooo/p/16289385.html
Copyright © 2020-2023  润新知