SQL> select * from a1;
ID NAME
---------- ----------
1 a
1 a
2 a
3 a
SQL> select * from a2;
ID
----------
2
3
2
SQL> select * from a1 where id not in (select id from a2);
ID NAME
---------- ----------
1 a
1 a
SQL> select a1.* from a1,a2
2 where a1.id=a2.id(+)
3 and a2.id is null;
ID NAME
---------- ----------
1 a
1 a