git rerere

zz:git-scm.com/2010/03/08/rerere.html

One of the things I didn't touch on at all in the book is the git rerere functionality. This also came up recently during one of my trainings, and I realize that a lot of people probably could use this, so I wanted to let you all now about it.

The git rerere functionality is a bit of a hidden feature (Git actually has a lot of cool hidden features, if you haven't figured that out yet). The name stands for "reuse recorded resolution" and as the name implies, it allows you to ask Git to remember how you've resolved a hunk conflict so that the next time it sees the same conflict, Git can automatically resolve it for you.

There are a number of scenarios in which this functionality might be really handy. One of the examples that is mentioned in the documentation is if you want to make sure a long lived topic branch will merge cleanly but don't want to have a bunch of intermediate merge commits. With rerere turned on you can merge occasionally, resolve the conflicts, then back out the merge. If you do this continuously, then the final merge should be easy because rerere can just do everything for you automatically.

This same tactic can be used if you want to keep a branch rebased so you don't have to deal with the same rebasing conflicts each time you do it. Or if you want to take a branch that you merged and fixed a bunch of conflicts and then decide to rebase it instead - you likely won't have to do all the same conflicts again.

The other situation I can think of is where you merge a bunch of evolving topic branches together into a testable head occasionally. If the tests fail, you can rewind the merges and re-do them without the topic branch that made the tests fail without having to re-resolve the conflicts again.

To enable the rerere functionality, you simply have to run this config setting:

$ git config --global rerere.enabled 1

You can also turn it on by creating the .git/rr-cache directory in a specific repository, but I think the config setting is clearer, and it can be done globally.

Now let's see a simple example. If we have a file that looks like this:

#! /usr/bin/env ruby

def hello
  puts 'hello world'
end

and in one branch we change the word 'hello' to 'hola', then in another branch we change the 'world' to 'mundo'.

When we merge the two branches together, we'll get a merge conflict:

$ git merge i18n-world
Auto-merging hello.rb
CONFLICT (content): Merge conflict in hello.rb
Recorded preimage for 'hello.rb'
Automatic merge failed; fix conflicts and then commit the result.

You should notice the new line Recorded preimage for FILE in there. Otherwise it should look exactly like a normal merge conflict. At this point, rerere can tell us some stuff. Normally, you might run git status at this point to see what all conflicted:

$ git status
# On branch master
# Unmerged paths:
#   (use "git reset HEAD <file>..." to unstage)
#   (use "git add <file>..." to mark resolution)
#
#   both modified:      hello.rb
#

However, git rerere will also tell you what it has recorded the pre-merge state for with git rerere status:

$ git rerere status
hello.rb

And git rerere diff will show the current state of the resolution - what you started with to resolve and what you've resolved it to.

$ git rerere diff
--- a/hello.rb
+++ b/hello.rb
@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
 #! /usr/bin/env ruby

 def hello
-<<<<<<<
-  puts 'hello mundo'
-=======
+<<<<<<< HEAD
   puts 'hola world'
->>>>>>>
+=======
+  puts 'hello mundo'
+>>>>>>> i18n-world
 end

Also (and this isn't really related to rerere), you can use ls-files -u to see the conflicted files and the before, left and right versions:

$ git ls-files -u
100644 39804c942a9c1f2c03dc7c5ebcd7f3e3a6b97519 1   hello.rb
100644 a440db6e8d1fd76ad438a49025a9ad9ce746f581 2   hello.rb
100644 54336ba847c3758ab604876419607e9443848474 3   hello.rb

Anyhow, so now you resolve it to just be "puts 'hola mundo'" and you can run the rerere diff command again to see what rerere will remember:

$ git rerere diff
--- a/hello.rb
+++ b/hello.rb
@@ -1,11 +1,7 @@
 #! /usr/bin/env ruby

 def hello
-<<<<<<<
-  puts 'hello mundo'
-=======
-  puts 'hola world'
->>>>>>>
+  puts 'hola mundo'
 end

So that basically says, when I see a hunk conflict that has 'hello mundo' on one side and 'hola world' on the other, resolve it to 'hola mundo'.

Now we can mark it as resolved and commit it:

$ git add hello.rb
$ git commit
Recorded resolution for 'hello.rb'.
[master 68e16e5] Merge branch 'i18n'

You can see that it "Recorded resolution for FILE".

Now, let's undo that merge and then rebase it on top of our master branch instead.

$ git reset --hard HEAD^
HEAD is now at ad63f15 i18n the hello

Our merge is undone. Now let's rebase the topic branch.

$ git checkout i18n-world
Switched to branch 'i18n-world'
$ git rebase master
First, rewinding head to replay your work on top of it...
Applying: i18n one word
Using index info to reconstruct a base tree...
Falling back to patching base and 3-way merge...
Auto-merging hello.rb
CONFLICT (content): Merge conflict in hello.rb
Resolved 'hello.rb' using previous resolution.
Failed to merge in the changes.
Patch failed at 0001 i18n one word

Now, we got the same merge conflict like we expected, but check out the Resolved FILE using previous resolution line. If we look at the file, we'll see that it's already been resolved:

$ cat hello.rb
#! /usr/bin/env ruby

def hello
  puts 'hola mundo'
end

Also, git diff will show you how it was automatically re-resolved:

$ git diff
diff --cc hello.rb
index a440db6,54336ba..0000000
--- a/hello.rb
+++ b/hello.rb
@@@ -1,7 -1,7 +1,7 @@@
  #! /usr/bin/env ruby

  def hello
-   puts 'hola world'
 -  puts 'hello mundo'
++  puts 'hola mundo'
  end

You can also recreate the conflicted file state with the checkout command:

$ git checkout --conflict=merge hello.rb
$ cat hello.rb
#! /usr/bin/env ruby

def hello
<<<<<<< ours
  puts 'hola world'
=======
  puts 'hello mundo'
>>>>>>> theirs
end

That might be a new command to you as well, the --conflict option to git checkout. You can actually have checkout do a couple of things in this situation to help you resolve conflicts. Another interesting value for that option is 'diff3', which will give you left, right and common to help you resolve the conflict manually:

$ git checkout --conflict=diff3 hello.rb
$ cat hello.rb
#! /usr/bin/env ruby

def hello
<<<<<<< ours
  puts 'hola world'
|||||||
  puts 'hello world'
=======
  puts 'hello mundo'
>>>>>>> theirs
end

Anyhow, then you can re-resolve it by just running rerere again:

$ git rerere
Resolved 'hello.rb' using previous resolution.
$ cat hello.rb
#! /usr/bin/env ruby

def hello
  puts 'hola mundo'
end

Magical re-resolving! Then you can add and continue the rebase to complete it.

$ git add hello.rb
$ git rebase --continue
Applying: i18n one word

So, if you do a lot of re-merges, or want to keep a topic branch up to date with your master branch without a ton of merges, or you rebase often or any of the above, turn on rerere to help your life out a bit.

git rerere使用问题：

I'm using git rerere, and it is useful, but there is one problem:
When it automatically resolves a file, it does not mark it as resolved (eg with git add). So if I run 'git mergetool', it opens up the file as if it still has all the conflicts in it.

So far, I've made a small shell script which I can call, which scans all files marked as conflicted for conflict markers (eg >>>>>>>), and calls git-add on them if they have none.

Is there a better way of doing this? Some flag to git rerere I missed?

->

Maybe a git config setting can help:

git config --global rerere.autoupdate

    When set to true, git-rerere updates the index with the resulting contents after it cleanly resolves conflicts using previously recorded resolution.
    Defaults to false.

Note: since Git1.7.0,

    "git rerere" had rerere.autoupdate configuration but there was no way to countermand it from the command line;
    --no-rerere-autoupdate option given to "merge", "revert", etc. fixes this.