Permission failure: android.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT 解决办法

在 android M 以上，MediaRecorder 录音时音源设置为 VOICE_CALL，开始录音时会抛出权限异常

12-04 10:34:41.808   545  2254 D AudioRecord: set(): 0xe90ba000, inputSource 4, sampleRate 44100, format 0x1, channelMask 0x10, frameCount 2048, notificationFrames 1024, sessionId 0, transferType 0, flags 0, opPackageName cn.wangy.contacts uid 10059, pid 1917
12-04 10:34:41.814   409  2559 W ServiceManager: Permission failure: android.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT from uid=10059 pid=1917
12-04 10:34:41.815   409  2559 D PermissionCache: checking android.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT for uid=10059 => denied (548 us)
12-04 10:34:41.815   409  2559 E         : Request requires android.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT
12-04 10:34:41.815   409  2559 E AudioFlinger: createRecord() checkRecordThread_l failed
12-04 10:34:41.815   545  2254 E IAudioFlinger: createRecord returned error -22
12-04 10:34:41.815   545  2254 E AudioRecord: AudioFlinger could not create record track, status: -22
12-04 10:34:41.816   545  2254 E StagefrightRecorder: audio source is not initialized
12-04 10:34:41.816   545  2254 D MPEG4Writer: reset+ 1081
12-04 10:34:41.816  1917  1917 E MediaRecorder: start failed: -2147483648
12-04 10:34:41.816  1917  1917 W System.err: java.lang.RuntimeException: start failed.
12-04 10:34:41.825  1917  1917 W System.err: 	at android.media.MediaRecorder.start(Native Method)

方法一，给 app 增加 sharedUserId="android.uid.system"，并使用系统签名

方法二，屏蔽系统源码，跳过权限检查

通过全局搜索，发现权限判断竟然在 c 中，通过 pid 和 vid 来检查

frameworksavservicesaudiopolicyserviceAudioPolicyInterfaceImpl.cpp
frameworksavservicesaudioflingerServiceUtilities.cpp

android 8.1
注释 AudioPolicyInterfaceImpl.cpp 中 switch 语句块 status = PERMISSION_DENIED;
或者修改 ServiceUtilities.cpp 中 captureAudioOutputAllowed() 返回 true

if (status == NO_ERROR) {
            // enforce permission (if any) required for each type of input
            switch (inputType) {
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_LEGACY:
                break;
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_TELEPHONY_RX:
                // FIXME: use the same permission as for remote submix for now.
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_MIX_CAPTURE:
                if (!captureAudioOutputAllowed(pid, uid)) {
                    ALOGE("getInputForAttr() permission allowed: capture allowed");
                    //cczheng annotation for don't check android.Manifest.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT
                    /*ALOGE("getInputForAttr() permission denied: capture not allowed");
                    status = PERMISSION_DENIED;*/
                }
                break;
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_MIX_EXT_POLICY_REROUTE:
                if (!modifyAudioRoutingAllowed()) {
                    ALOGE("getInputForAttr() permission denied: modify audio routing not allowed");
                    status = PERMISSION_DENIED;
                }
                break;
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_INVALID:
            default:
                LOG_ALWAYS_FATAL("getInputForAttr() encountered an invalid input type %d",
                        (int)inputType);
            }
        }

android 9.0

9.0 中 AudioPolicyInterfaceImpl.cpp 在 switch 语句块前新增加了包名判断，上面的报错权限就是从这里打印的，注释如下

// check calling permissions
    //cczheng annotation for don't check android.Manifest.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT
    /*if (!recordingAllowed(opPackageName, pid, uid)) {
        ALOGE("%s permission denied: recording not allowed for uid %d pid %d",
                __func__, uid, pid);
        return PERMISSION_DENIED;
    }

    if ((attr->source == AUDIO_SOURCE_VOICE_UPLINK ||
        attr->source == AUDIO_SOURCE_VOICE_DOWNLINK ||
        attr->source == AUDIO_SOURCE_VOICE_CALL) &&
        !captureAudioOutputAllowed(pid, uid)) {
        return PERMISSION_DENIED;
    }*/

    if ((attr->source == AUDIO_SOURCE_HOTWORD) && !captureHotwordAllowed(pid, uid)) {
        return BAD_VALUE;
    }

    sp<AudioPolicyEffects>audioPolicyEffects;
    {
        status_t status;
        AudioPolicyInterface::input_type_t inputType;

        Mutex::Autolock _l(mLock);
        {
            AutoCallerClear acc;
            // the audio_in_acoustics_t parameter is ignored by get_input()
            status = mAudioPolicyManager->getInputForAttr(attr, input, session, uid,
                                                         config,
                                                         flags, selectedDeviceId,
                                                         &inputType, portId);
        }
        audioPolicyEffects = mAudioPolicyEffects;

        if (status == NO_ERROR) {
            // enforce permission (if any) required for each type of input
            switch (inputType) {
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_LEGACY:
                break;
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_TELEPHONY_RX:
                // FIXME: use the same permission as for remote submix for now.
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_MIX_CAPTURE:
                if (!captureAudioOutputAllowed(pid, uid)) {
                    ALOGE("getInputForAttr() permission allowed: capture allowed");
                    //cczheng annotation for don't check android.Manifest.permission.CAPTURE_AUDIO_OUTPUT
                    /*ALOGE("getInputForAttr() permission denied: capture not allowed");
                    status = PERMISSION_DENIED;*/
                }
                break;
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_MIX_EXT_POLICY_REROUTE:
                if (!modifyAudioRoutingAllowed()) {
                    ALOGE("getInputForAttr() permission denied: modify audio routing not allowed");
                    status = PERMISSION_DENIED;
                }
                break;
            case AudioPolicyInterface::API_INPUT_INVALID:
            default:
                LOG_ALWAYS_FATAL("getInputForAttr() encountered an invalid input type %d",
                        (int)inputType);
            }
        }