如何测试netty 的流量整形呢？ 因为 其实服务端、客户端都可以限速，读写也可以限速，有多个组合，所以比较复杂；
考虑一种最简单的情况，就是单独对客户端写进行限速，如下：
服务端等待客户端连接；接受客户端请求之后，打印每秒收到的数据有多少， 然后简单打印一下速率；怎么做呢？ 服务端对每一个客户端的channel保存一个计数器用于统计收到的总流量大小consumeMsgLength，然后启动一个定时器，每秒执行一次，任务是把consumeMsgLength 打印一下，然后置为0 （相当于是重置）；
客户端连接到服务端，然后发送请求，比如是每秒随机写10M，也就是 10M/s 的写（当然也可以 设置一个范围，如 1~10 M/s ，客户端固定速度的写是为了 测试方便起见， 实际情况可能非常不同），但是限速是每秒1M，也就是 rate = 1M/s；那么 客户端理论上发送的数据 会有多少， 应该是1M/s， 多余的数据到哪里去了？ 其实控制好就不会有这种问题。因为客户端应该进行控制，一定要根据 客制化的可写性判断，允许写才写！
下面是我测试通过的代码以及说明。
服务端关键代码
ServerBootstrap sbs = new ServerBootstrap(); // 配置nio服务参数 sbs.group(bossGroup, workerGroup) .channel(NioServerSocketChannel.class) // 说明一个新的Channel如何接收进来的连接 .option(ChannelOption.SO_BACKLOG, 128) // tcp最大缓存链接个数 .childOption(ChannelOption.SO_KEEPALIVE, true) //保持连接 .handler(new LoggingHandler(LogLevel.INFO)) // 打印日志级别 .childHandler(new ChannelInitializer<SocketChannel>() { @Override protected void initChannel(SocketChannel socketChannel) throws Exception { // 处理接收到的请求 ChannelPipeline pipeline = socketChannel.pipeline(); // 基于换行符号 // pipeline.addLast(new LineBasedFrameDecoder(1024)); // 这个会导致 channelRead0 没有执行，因为 数据一直在接收之中.. 等待一个换行 // 解码转String，注意调整自己的编码格式GBK、UTF-8 pipeline.addLast(new StringDecoder(Charset.forName("GBK"))); // 解码转String，注意调整自己的编码格式GBK、UTF-8 pipeline.addLast(new StringEncoder(Charset.forName("GBK"))); //流量整形 // pipeline.addLast(new ChannelTrafficShapingHandler(10, 10)); pipeline.addLast(new MyServerCommonHandler( ));
管道处理器：
import io.netty.channel.*; import java.util.Date; import java.util.Optional; import java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicLong; import java.util.function.Consumer; public class MyServerCommonHandler extends ChannelInboundHandlerAdapter { protected final int KB = 1024;// * 1024; protected String tempStr; protected AtomicLong consumeMsgLength; protected Runnable counterTask; protected boolean sentFlag; @Override public void channelWritabilityChanged(ChannelHandlerContext ctx) throws Exception { if(ctx.channel().isWritable() && !sentFlag) { System.out.println(" ###### 重新开始写数据 ######"); } else { System.out.println(" ===== 写暂停 ====="); } } @Override public void handlerAdded(ChannelHandlerContext ctx) throws Exception { System.out.println("MyServerCommonHandler.handlerAdded"); consumeMsgLength = new AtomicLong(); counterTask = () -> { while (true) { try { Thread.sleep(1000); } catch (InterruptedException e) { } long length = consumeMsgLength.getAndSet(0); System.out.println("*** " + ctx.channel().remoteAddress() + " rate（KB/S）：" + (length) + " " + new Date()); } }; StringBuilder builder = new StringBuilder(); for (int i = 0; i < KB; i++) { builder.append("abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz"); } tempStr = builder.toString(); super.handlerAdded(ctx); } @Override public void channelActive(ChannelHandlerContext ctx) throws Exception { new Thread(counterTask).start(); } protected abstract void sentData(ChannelHandlerContext ctx); @Override public void channelRead(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, Object msg) throws Exception { if (msg instanceof String) { int length = ((String) msg).length(); // // 为什么这里 是默认 15s 一次， 因为io.netty.handler.traffic.AbstractTrafficShapingHandler.DEFAULT_MAX_TIME = 15 000 long l = consumeMsgLength.addAndGet(length);// 为什么每次都是 10240 ？ 因为客户端写过来的数据就是这么多 System.out.println("===== receive client " + " " + " size:" + l); } // System.out.println("===== receive client msg : " + msg + " " + l); super.channelRead(ctx, msg); } }
客户端
@Override protected void initChannel(SocketChannel socketChannel) throws Exception { // 处理来自服务端的响应信息 ChannelPipeline pipeline = socketChannel.pipeline(); ChannelTrafficShapingHandler channelTrafficShapingHandler = new MyChannelTrafficShapingHandler((long) (0.001 * KB), 1 * KB); // 解码转String，注意调整自己的编码格式GBK、UTF-8 pipeline.addLast(new StringDecoder(Charset.forName("GBK"))); // 解码转String，注意调整自己的编码格式GBK、UTF-8 pipeline.addLast(new StringEncoder(Charset.forName("GBK"))); pipeline .addLast("channelTrafficShapingHandler",channelTrafficShapingHandler) .addLast(new ClientOutHandler())
上面设置是：writeLimit = 0.001 * KB，也就是 每秒最多写 0.001 * KB，
管道处理器：
import com.zx.sms.testNetty.Student; import io.netty.buffer.ByteBuf; import io.netty.channel.ChannelHandlerContext; import io.netty.channel.ChannelInboundHandlerAdapter; import io.netty.channel.ChannelOutboundHandlerAdapter; import io.netty.channel.ChannelPromise; import io.netty.util.ReferenceCountUtil; import java.net.SocketAddress; import java.nio.charset.Charset; import java.util.Date; /** * 读取服务器返回的响应信息 * @author luo * */ public class ClientOutHandler extends ChannelOutboundHandlerAdapter { @Override public void write(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, Object msg, ChannelPromise promise) throws Exception { System.out.println("write = " + new Date() + " ctx.channel().isWritable() " + ctx.channel().isWritable()); super.write(ctx, msg, promise); } @Override public void disconnect(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, ChannelPromise promise) throws Exception { System.out.println("ClientOutHandler.disconnect" + new Date()); super.disconnect(ctx, promise); } @Override public void read(ChannelHandlerContext ctx) throws Exception { System.out.println("ClientOutHandler.read" + new Date()); super.read(ctx); } @Override public void close(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, ChannelPromise promise) throws Exception { System.out.println("ClientOutHandler.close" + new Date()); super.close(ctx, promise); } @Override public void connect(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, SocketAddress remoteAddress, SocketAddress localAddress, ChannelPromise promise) throws Exception { System.out.println("ctx = [" + ctx + "], remoteAddress = [" + remoteAddress + "], localAddress = [" + localAddress + "], promise = [" + promise + "]" + new Date()); super.connect(ctx, remoteAddress, localAddress, promise); new Thread() { @Override public void run() { StringBuilder builder = new StringBuilder(); for (int i = 0; i < 1024*1; i++) { builder.append("abcdefghij"); } int cnt = 0; String o = builder.toString(); while (cnt < 1000) { try { Thread.sleep(100); } catch (InterruptedException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } boolean writable = ctx.channel().isWritable(); /* 因为io.netty.handler.traffic.AbstractTrafficShapingHandler.DEFAULT_MAX_TIME 所以 无论， 都会写一次。 */ if (writable) { ctx.channel().writeAndFlush(o); } else{ // System.out.println("ClientOutHandler.run ctx.channel().isWritable() no"); } cnt++; } } }.start(); } @Override public void flush(ChannelHandlerContext ctx) throws Exception { super.flush(ctx); } @Override public void deregister(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, ChannelPromise promise) throws Exception { System.out.println("ctx = [" + ctx + "], promise = [" + promise + "] " + new Date() + " ctx.channel().isWritable() " + ctx.channel().isWritable()); super.deregister(ctx, promise); } @Override public void handlerAdded(ChannelHandlerContext ctx) throws Exception { System.out.println("ctx = [" + ctx + "] " + new Date()); super.handlerAdded(ctx); } }
和guava 的RateLimiter 不同，netty的 TrafficShapingHandler也是 先等待（最久等待默认是15s ），然后 时间到了，然后读或者写， 不管数据量有多大。
也就是说， 如果 rate = 1M/s， 第一次写100M数据，按理说是需要 100s， 但是实际上只会等待15s， 然后就把100 m， 一次性写过去。 也就是说， 存在突刺的情况！
当然， 其实现原理也是差别很大。
测试，服务端日志：
*** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:21 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:22 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:10240 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 20:38:22 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：10240 Sat May 29 20:38:23 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:24 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:25 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:26 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:27 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:28 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:29 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:30 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:31 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:32 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:33 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:34 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:35 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:36 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:37 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:10240 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 20:38:37 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：10240 Sat May 29 20:38:38 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:39 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:40 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:41 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:42 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:43 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:44 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:45 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:46 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:47 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:48 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:49 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:50 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:51 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:52 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:10240 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 20:38:52 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：10240 Sat May 29 20:38:53 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:33533 rate（KB/S）：0 Sat May 29 20:38:54 CST 2021
客户端打印：
write = Sat May 29 20:37:37 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 20:37:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 20:38:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 20:38:22 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 20:38:37 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 20:38:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 20:39:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true
可见， 每秒统计速度，都是0，但是每15秒就写一次。 receive client size:10240 打印的就是 实际接受的数据， 符合预期！
需要注意的是， 客户端写限速之后，客户端执行ctx.channel().writeAndFlush(o) 方法需要先判断一下 是否可写。否则限速就完全无效！！！
因为 ChannelTrafficShapingHandler 实际上不做限制，而是 仅仅给对应的通道做一个标记！
如果改一下， 把
ClientOutHandler#connect 的 builder.append("abcdefghij"); 改为 builder.append("a");
new MyChannelTrafficShapingHandler((long) (0.001 * KB), 1 * KB); 改为 new MyChannelTrafficShapingHandler((long) (1 * KB), 1 * KB);
也就是 每次写 1024 B，每秒10次即每秒写 10240 B即 10 KB， 限速也是 1 KB， 那么， 应该来说，是每秒 可以写 10次，观察 客户端日志：
write = Sat May 29 23:14:34 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:34 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:34 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:39 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:39 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:39 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:39 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:39 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:44 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:44 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:44 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:44 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:44 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:49 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:49 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:49 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:49 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:49 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:54 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:54 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:54 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:54 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:54 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:59 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:59 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:59 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:59 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:14:59 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:04 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:04 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:04 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:04 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:04 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:09 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:09 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:09 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:09 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:09 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:14 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:14 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:14 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:14 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:14 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:19 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:19 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:19 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:19 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:19 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:24 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:15:24 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true
服务端日志：
===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:25 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:25 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:26 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:26 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:27 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:27 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:28 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:28 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:29 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:29 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:30 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:30 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:31 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:31 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:32 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:32 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:33 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:33 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:34 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:34 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:35 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:35 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:36 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:36 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:37 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:37 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:38 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:38 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:39 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:39 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:45:40 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:40279 rate（KB/S）：1024 Sat May 29 23:45:40 CST 2021
可见并不符合预期！
发现并不是 预设的那样， 实际隔5秒 写一次，一次写5行（5个write操作）！ 但是 平均来说 它确实是每秒 只能写一次！
竟然有假的 可写性修改。 为什么会这样， 从 io.netty.handler.traffic.AbstractTrafficShapingHandler#checkWriteSuspend 找到答案：
void checkWriteSuspend(ChannelHandlerContext ctx, long delay, long queueSize) { if (queueSize > maxWriteSize || delay > maxWriteDelay) { setUserDefinedWritability(ctx, false); } }
maxWriteSize默认值是4M，maxWriteDelay 默认值是4s， 就是说默认只有 当前写大小超过了4M或总延迟超过4s，才会实际的修改 管道可写性， 否则不会改变。 虽然少量的延迟不会立即修改可写性，所以写操作会理解提交到管道之后，所以看到上面的一秒5行的写日志， 而且服务端能够立即收到数据（ 每秒一次一KB）。但是效果延迟会积累，所以，超过5s之后的写 还是需要等到 5s 之后，所以看到上面的 每隔5行的写新的日志 。
其他不变，如果 改为 new MyChannelTrafficShapingHandler((long) (2 * KB), 1 * KB); 那么 服务端每秒收到2次写，每次1KB， 即 rate = 2k/s ；
服务端：
===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:23 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:2048 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:24 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:41167 rate（KB/S）：2048 Sat May 29 23:53:24 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:24 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:2048 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:25 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:41167 rate（KB/S）：2048 Sat May 29 23:53:25 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:25 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:2048 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:26 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:41167 rate（KB/S）：2048 Sat May 29 23:53:26 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:26 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:2048 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:27 CST 2021 *** /127.0.0.1:41167 rate（KB/S）：2048 Sat May 29 23:53:27 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:1024 MyServerCommonHandler.channelReadComplete Sat May 29 23:53:27 CST 2021 ===== receive client size:2048
发现其中 ===== receive client 打印了 2次， 分别是1024 2048 ，rate（KB/S）才打印一次 固定是 2048，这个是因为 服务端收到2次（每次手动1KB数据）后才会清零计数器。 rate 是正确的，其他打印也是正确的！
客户端：
write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:52 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:53 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:53 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:53 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:53 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:57 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:57 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:57 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:57 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:57 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:57 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:58 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:58 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:58 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:51:58 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:02 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:02 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:02 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:02 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:02 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:02 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:03 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:03 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:03 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:03 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:07 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:08 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:08 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:08 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:08 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:15 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:16 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:21 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:21 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:21 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:21 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:21 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:21 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:22 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:22 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:22 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:22 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:26 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:26 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:26 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:26 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:26 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:26 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:27 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:27 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:27 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:27 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:34 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:35 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:40 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:40 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:40 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:40 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:40 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:40 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:41 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:41 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:41 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:41 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:45 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:45 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:45 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:45 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:45 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:45 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:46 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:46 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true write = Sat May 29 23:52:46 CST 2021 ctx.channel().isWritable() true
观察发现 基本上 平均是 每5秒写10次，一次一行一kB！ 就是翻倍了， 即 avg rate = 2k/s！
如果 客户端一次写的 内容 超过4M 它也不会被发开为 多次写， 而是在等待之后立即写。 不管写数据量是多少，默认超过15s 就要写完！
总体来说， 符合预期，限流确实是有效果了， 但是 限流结果并不是 平滑直线，而是可能出现突刺 ！
--------------------------------------------- 更正 -----------------------------------------
更正， 仔细测试，观察上面服务端的日志发现，服务端收到是数据是平滑的， 是没有突刺的！ 仅仅从上面客户端的日志来看，似乎是“每5秒写10次，一次一行一kB”，似乎存在突刺， 但是 为什么服务端收到的数据不是的呢？
其实不是这样的！ 再次检查源码， 注意@1 处，发现：
void submitWrite(final ChannelHandlerContext ctx, final Object msg, final long size, final long delay, final long now, final ChannelPromise promise) { final ToSend newToSend; // write order control synchronized (this) { if (delay == 0 && messagesQueue.isEmpty()) { trafficCounter.bytesRealWriteFlowControl(size); ctx.write(msg, promise); return; } newToSend = new ToSend(delay + now, msg, promise); messagesQueue.addLast(newToSend); queueSize += size; checkWriteSuspend(ctx, delay, queueSize); // @1 } final long futureNow = newToSend.relativeTimeAction; ctx.executor().schedule(new Runnable() { @Override public void run() { sendAllValid(ctx, futureNow); } }, delay, TimeUnit.MILLISECONDS); }
checkWriteSuspend 方法其实没有返回值，就是说它 仅仅是一个优化，即使没有立即的设置管道的可写性，也仅仅是影响可写性，如果此时有数据继续可过来， 此时会写到本地内存缓存中去！ 而且，只要delay != 0 ,那么就不会立即return，那么就会提交一个延迟任务（不管是否可写），任务的执行是时间是未来时间： futureNow 。
如果把写速度不变，限速提高到1MB，那么就是相当于没有了限速。
按理说，当前提交了1个延迟任务，sendAllValid 方法就会执行对应的1次的写！ 但是从sendAllValid源码来看，它有一个循环， 当内存中的缓冲队列messagesQueue 写完为空之后，又会release WriteSuspended （ 后面的需要等待前面的写完） 如果第1秒的时候 一个请求req1 过来，写很多数据，需要延迟10s 即第11s执行； 如果第2秒的时候 又一个请求req2 过来，写很多数据，需要延迟3s 即第5s执行，那么 req2 是会比req1 先执行吗？ 还是说必须排队到 req1之后？ 观察 io.netty.handler.traffic.TrafficCounter#writeTimeToWait(long, long, long, long) 可知，返回的wait 即 delay 是在本窗口中递增的数值，是第二个情况， 所以 req2 实际是 10 +3 第13s执行， 所以 第10秒 写完 req1之后， messagesQueue 还有一个数据，不为空 ，所以 保证了 release WriteSuspended 不是很频繁， 不会反复的被无谓的执行。
所以一般就是先wait的先write，但是 并发的情况下就不一定了！ 所以上面 还有synchronized 加锁。
综上，基本上来说 客户端的数据 也都是按照设定的时间写出去的，大部分是平滑的。 但是如果发送的速度过快或数据量过大超出了限速，那么仍然有可能在超时的时刻有突刺。
futureNow